A place where sceptics can exchange their views

Monday, 28 December 2020

Fishermen let down by Brexit deal - you just have to suck it up

It seems that a majority of fishermen voted for Brexit in the belief that they would be freed from the constraints of the EU common fisheries policy. Britain would become a sovereign coastal state which would be free to do as it liked and british fishermen would be able to obtain the lion's share of fish caught in British coastal waters.  It now seems that they feel they have been sold down the river.

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2020/dec/26/deal-fishing-industry-boris-johnson-betrayal-eu-demands

You were warned what would happen by the remain campaign and it is no use complaining if you voted for Brexit. Sovereignty does not work the way you wish it to. Every country in the world including the US has to compromise on sovereignty when they join organisations such as NATO, The WTO and the UN. The US is obliged to send its daughters and sons into death or danger to protect Latvia if it is attacked. The UK is a member of NATO and must do the same. The UK and the US pool their sovereignty for the greater good. Brexiters have never really understood this. They have thought ideologically. They have decided to leave the EU simply because they do not like their fellow Europeans from having any say in British affairs. They also voted to leave the EU because they resented Romanian  and Bulgarians being allowed to come to Britain "freely" to pick strawberries.

The Fishermen, are now confronted with the "realpolitik" of international relations as all their hopes and dreams have been dashed.To get a poor trade deal for the rest of the UK their dreams had to be sacrificed, and they have probably ended up in a worse position than before we left the EU. Their fellow citizens by a small majority voted for this.

Britain cannot afford to be totally sovereign and soon we will hear other complaints. British companies will now be forced to fill in mountains of paperwork to export to the EU and this will increase the price of their products on the EU market - our biggest one. There will be delays to exports and this will increase prices. Britain will become a less attractive place to invest in for institutional investors. Young people won't be able to get temporary jobs in Europe. EU students will be reluctant to come to British universities because of visa requirements and extra costs  and this will affect revenues. There will be queues at the borders for British people to travel to Europe. British businessmen and women will be denied seats on the boards of EU companies unless they have a visa. The problems will be endless.

There will be an EU border down the Irish Sea. Would the US allow an EU border between New York and New Jersey states? A weakened Britain has no choice but to accept the humiliation of giving away its sovereignty. The EU and the US forced us to do this to ensure peace in Ireland. The EU-UK Withdrawal Agreement and Trade Deals offered you a Turbot  but you got a Sand Eel  which is about to go rotten. Don't complain if you voted for it, this is the price you pay for an imaginary absolute sovereignty.

Thursday, 17 December 2020

C19 Epidemic

 How could a country get into such a mess over the C19 epidemic? The relaxation of the social distancing rules for Christmas is bordering on the irresponsible. In London, where I live, the cases of C19 are rising sharply despite the latest lockdown. The rise in infections is being driven by the schools not being able to ensure social distancing amongst the pupils. We have been warned by the WHO that wearing masks is insufficient to prevent the spread of the virus. This is something that I worked out for myself months ago. To curb infections everyone must adopt distancing measures of at least one meter and practice hand hygiene as well as wearing masks in confined spaces. Clearly this is not working in schools.


The WHO also recommends targeted testing and the  isolation of anyone who has contracted the virus. Clearly this is not working despite billions of pounds being spent on the national system. Test and isolation is best left to the local public health authorities but they have been starved of funds and resources. 

The best course of action to control the virus would have been to lock down the nation whilst the pupils were off school. With a bit of imagination lonely or old people could have been catered for without risking their health or anyone else's.

The WHO is not recommending a Christmas free for all for good reason.

As I have said before, we have become a decadent society where excellence hardly exists. Let's hope most people ignore the Christmas relaxation of social distancing rules. The the nation's health and its economy will then be given a chance to recover. Recovery will require careful thought, planning and self control and not sudden changes of mind, otherwise we shall drift from one lockdown to another and thousands more will die unnecessarily and thousands more businesses will go broke. This is not a good prospect for our nation. The best advice is stay at home but I fear vast numbers will not follow it.